aeroflot flight 593 crash site

It was a night flight and everything was going smooth; 4 and half hours into the flight, the aeroplane was flying over Siberia. Like many other autopilots on Western aircraft but unlike those on Soviet models the A310 autopilots lateral and vertical channels could each disconnect independently under specific circumstances, without affecting the other. In 1992, the special brand was allegedly launched under the name Russian Airlines, while Aeroflot as a whole was rebranded as Aeroflot Russian International Airlines, or ARIA a change meant to emphasize the airlines new role as a flag carrier, although ultimately the branding would not stick, as Aeroflot turned inward once more in the 2000s. Under the command economy in the Soviet Union, air travel was effectively a form of public transportation, with artificially low fares, a network geared toward maximum coverage rather than profitability, and passenger cabins and in-flight service which were, in the words of Paul Duffy of Aviation Week, more akin to [those] of a South American railway service, than of an airline. The planes engines were noisy and inefficient, their seats were uncomfortable, and safety questions left foreigners hesitant to board them. United Airlines Flight 93 was a passenger flight that was hijacked by four al-Qaeda terrorists on board, as part of the September 11 attacks. Well get out now! A Brief History On March 23, 1994, one of the worst excuses for an airliner crash happened when an Aeroflot pilot allowed his 12 and 16-year-old children to play with the controls of the Airbus A310-300 that he was flying, resulting in a crash that killed all 75 people aboard! The right bank increased from six to fifteen degrees, then started to go back to the left as the plane rolled out on its intended heading. Five people were thus on the flight deck: Kudrinsky, co-pilot Piskaryov, Kudrinsky's children Eldar and Yana,and another pilot, Vladimir Makarov, who was flying as a passenger. All the while, the feedback force on the control column increased until, at 00:55 and 29 seconds, the autopilots lateral channel quietly disconnected. 310 pilot wife jamie. In response to the autopilots inputs, the control column turned to the left beneath Yanas hands, giving her a simulation of what it might feel like to fly the plane. Seeing them there, anger melts into sadness. And so at 00:43, he turned to his 12-year-old daughter and said, Come and sit here now, in my seat, would you like that?. As the autopilot pitched up in the turn, the angle of attack that is, the angle of the airflow over the wings relative to the planes direction of travel began to increase rapidly. Although some accounts insinuate that Kudrinsky was trying to give her a convincing illusion of control, it appears his actions were merely demonstrative, as he explained what he was doing throughout the maneuver. After about eight seconds, by which time the plane had reached 21 degrees of left bank, Kudrinsky reached for the heading knob again, and turned it back to the right. Category:Aeroflot Flight 593. Needless to say, however, bringing children (usually boys) up to the flight deck while in the air was a longstanding tradition around the world prior to the post-9/11 crackdown on cockpit security breaches, and many people who grew up in the second half of the 20th century fondly recall receiving such invitations, typically without realizing that the practice was technically not allowed. To the left! This is the crash animation and audio log Vote 7 comments Best Add a Comment dmcdan8 18 min. There are 283 days left in the year. As Kudrinsky threw himself back into his seat, Piskaryov rolled hard to the left against the right yaw, and the plane stalled, spun around, and flipped violently upside down, hurtling into a spiral dive. Aeroflot Flight 593 was a passenger flight from Sheremetyevo International Airport, Moscow, Russia, to Kai Tak Airport in Hong Kong. The unnamed businessman could not have been aware that less than two months later, Aeroflots London-Moscow-Hong Kong service would plunge from the sky over Siberia due to what turned out to be an unprecedented act of unprofessionalism. A flight attendant died trying to help passengers escape the burning Aeroflot plane that was forced to make an emergency landing Sunday, Russian state media has reported. Investigators also criticized the training given to the pilots by Airbus during their transition to the A310. In the background, the cockpit voice recorder captured Kudrinsky conversing with Yana. In the event, the lateral channel disconnected when the roll force on the control columns reached 1113 kilograms, and did so with no warning whatsoever. >People on board had to sit through 30 mins of crazy phugoid cycles before finally crashing. The flight departed East Midlands at 9:38 local time in order to make a second attempt to land at the scheduled destination. Normal flight may have resumed if Piskaryov had simply let go of the controls, but instead he continued to hold his control column all the way back to the stop. The insidious aspect of this feature on the A310 was that the disconnection of one channel but not the other would fail to trigger either the visual or aural autopilot disconnect warnings. 0 . The 15-year-old Eldar was even more enthusiastic about the airplane than his sister, and Makarov, who was standing in the back of the cockpit, joked, Lets get a picture of the pilot!. Aeroflot Flight 593 was a passenger flight from Sheremetyevo International Airport, Moscow, Russia, to Kai Tak Airport in Hong Kong. The relief pilot Yaroslav Vladimirovich Kudrinsky's children - his 16-year-old son Eldar and his 12-year-old daughter Yana - were also among the passengers. This news leaked to the press almost immediately, but in incomplete form, and all sorts of wild rumors ensued, with various newspapers claiming that the pilots had left the cockpit entirely with the children at the controls, that Makarov the pilot riding as a passenger had intervened in an unsuccessful attempt to save the plane, and even that Eldar Kudrinsky was under the influence of prescription medications. After a little while, someone probably Eldar turned the wheel a little farther, and the rate of roll increased to two degrees per second. The transcript of the desperate final minutes before the March crash, published this week in the magazine Obozrevatel, reveals that the Russian crew almost succeeded in saving the plane. Investigators had largely held their tongue up until that point, but this was simply a step too far. Airbus had evidently not considered the possibility that pilots could inadvertently disengage one channel but not the other, or assumed that it would not be a big deal if they did an assumption which should have been proved wrong clear back in 1972, when Eastern Airlines flight 401 descended into the Florida Everglades after the pilots accidentally disengaged the vertical channel of the autopilot on their Lockheed L-1011 while attempting to fix a broken lightbulb. The aircraft carried registration F-OGQS and had only entered service with the airline at the end of 1992. The pilot's seat was soon occupied by Eldar Kudrinsky, pilot's son and he was able to contradict the autopilot for 30 seconds unlike her sister after applying enough force to the control column. Go to the back, go to the back Eldar! he screamed. Contribute to chinapedia/wikipedia.en development by creating an account on GitHub. The professional reputation of the A310 crews, praised so highly by Aviation Week, was left in tatters. At 13:39 UTC already after dark in Moscow flight 593 took off from Sheremetyevo Airport and climbed to its cruising altitude of 10,100 meters, approximately 33,300 feet. Piskaryov then managed to pull out of the dive, but over-corrected, putting the plane in an almost vertical ascent, again stalling the plane, which fell out of the sky into a corkscrew dive. Kudrinsky adjusted the autopilot's heading to give her the impression that she was turning the plane, though she actually had no control of the aircraft. Aeroflot Flight 593 burst into flames at Sheremetyevo airport on. >Deadliest single aircraft aviation accident in history. 19940323-0. Le vol TAROM 371 est un vol entre l'aroport international Henri Coand de Bucarest et l'aroport de Bruxelles, assur par un Airbus A310 qui s'est cras prs de Baloteti en Roumanie le 31 mars 1995.. L'avion s'est cras peu de temps aprs le dcollage. Aeroflot Flight 593 was a Airbus A310-304 The accident happened in 1994 63 passengers as well as 12 crew members died in the accident On the 23rd March 1994, Aeroflot Flight 593 which. 23-03-94: Aeroflot Flight 593 was an A310 passenger flight that carried 63 passengers and 12 crew members. Fifteen-year-old Eldar Kudrinsky and his 12-year-old sister Yana were among the 63 passengers, where they had been placed under the care of fellow passenger and off-duty Aeroflot pilot Vladimir Makarov, whose own daughter was on board as well. instance of. Aeroflot flight 593 crashed, killing everyone onboard. A second, larger indicator light came on to alert the pilots of the complete disengagement, and this time they did notice it. Furthermore, the disconnection threshold was met when the cumulative force on both control columns reached 1113 kilograms, meaning that Eldar and Piskaryov might each have been applying as little as 56 kilograms of force when the disconnection occurred. At the same time, however, most Western long-range airliners had far too many seats the passenger volume on Aeroflots routes was simply too low to justify buying 747s or MD-11s. ''2319 '''Kudrinsky:''' Eldar, get out! with this post, location or person. Unfortunately, Piskaryovs inputs led to a second stall, which was then turned into a stall-spin due to an ill-timed right rudder input. Aeroflot flight 593 The incident happened onboard an Aeroflot Airbus A310 aircraft on March 23rd 1993. Category:Aeroflot Flight 593 - Wikimedia Commons Help Category:Aeroflot Flight 593 From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository Media in category "Aeroflot Flight 593" This category contains only the following file. He turned his controls hard to the left, and the wings rolled level, pulling the plane out of its spiral. All 63 passengers and 12 crew members perished in the accident. Turn right! This training made no mention of the fact that the autopilot could partially disconnect, nor was this clearly explained in the flight crew operations manual. Before long, the plane reached 30 degrees of bank, the normal in-flight maximum, and then kept right on going, approaching 45. DNA: 'Soft corner' for China in Rahul's heart? An automatic system brought the plane out of its stall, and Piskaryov managed to recover from the dive, but he overcorrected, allowing the plane to pitch up too steeply likely in part because he physically could not reach far enough forward to push the nose down, although he may also have been disoriented by the rapid transition from descent to climb. The aircraft involved in the accident was a leased Airbus A310-304, registered as F-OGQS, serial number 596 and was powered by two General Electric CF6-80C2A2 engines. Identifiers. Aprs enqute, deux raisons principales sont voques pour expliquer cet accident : en premier, la commande de puissance du . Digging Deeper Most of the 63 passengers on Aeroflot Flight 593 were . This unique empathy is perhaps the reason why most retellings position Kudrinsky as a tragic hero, in the Greek sense, rather than the villain of his own story. For me, it's JAL123. Applying between 11 and 13 kilograms of roll force to the control column would disconnect the autopilots lateral channel, while a similar amount of force applied forward or backward would disconnect the vertical (pitch) channel, allowing a pilot to take control instantly without having to fight against a malfunctioning autopilot, and without having to waste time reaching for the autopilot disconnect button either. Russian International Airlines crashed into a mountain range in Kemerovo Oblast Russia killing all 63 . MOSCOW (AP) _ ''Daddy, can I turn this?'' The cockpit tapes record a chilling scene: the pilot's children getting a flying lesson just before the Aeroflot jet crashed in Siberia, killing all 75 people aboard. On the night of the 22nd of March, relief Captain Kudrinsky was using this policy to bring his children on their first ever trip abroad. Theres the ground! Piskaryov said, regaining his bearings. The plane had vanished from their radar screens, and their calls to the flight were met with a dreaded, unending silence. Published Feb 6, 2022. The father of crash victim Adrian Deauville perhaps put it best: I can forgive the pilots, he said. Within seconds, the angle of attack approached the stall threshold, and the airplane started to vibrate alarmingly. He presumably believed that with the plane on autopilot, any inputs Eldar might make would have no effect on the course of the flight. The relief pilot had two children (a boy aged 16 and a girl aged 12), and both of them were flying with him inside the cockpit! Countless pilots around the world had done the same, and no harm had ever come of it. Eldar, get out, get out! How to claim lost baggage from Saudi Airlines. Everything is okay! Kudrinsky yelled. Pull up gently!2400 (17:58:01 UTC) [Sound of impact, end of recording]. Russian Flight 593 Crash After Kid Disables Autopilot Aviation Insight 42.9K subscribers Subscribe 5.5K views 8 months ago UNITED STATES When you Like and Comment on the video then only. Well get out, well get out, well get out, said Piskaryov. On their flight management displays, the pre-programmed navigation track had been replaced by a curving white line ahead of the aircraft symbol, circling back the way they came. The two discuss Flight 593, new airline policies in the age of the pandemic, Harrison Fo DNA: PM Modi's scathing attack on the opposition. Analyzer of plane crashes. Aeroflot Flight 593 was a MoscowHong Kong passenger service operated by Aeroflot Russian International Airlines, flown with an Airbus A310-300, that crashed into a hillside of the Kuznetsk Alatau mountain range, Kemerovo Oblast, Russia, on 23 March 1994. See it turn? Kudrinsky said. DNA: Why has Congress become 'extinct' in the Northeast? I gave power, I gave it! Kudrinsky yelled. Aeroflotflt593.png 960 720; 475 KB Uses of Wikidata Infobox Uses of Wikidata Infobox with maps Pages with maps Go to the left, turn to the left!. On 23 March 1994, the aircraft operating the route, an Airbus A310-304 flown by Aeroflot, crashed into the Kuznetsk Alatau mountain range in Kemerovo Oblast, killing all 63 passengers and 12 crew members on board. Yes, I am, said Makarov, presumably wielding a camera. AeroflotFlight 593was a Moscow-Hong Kongpassenger service operated by Aeroflot - Russian International Airlines, flown with an Airbus A310-300, that crashed into a hillside of the Kuznetsk Alataumountain range, Kemerovo Oblast, Russia, on 23 March 1994. Captain Danilov and First Officer Piskaryov were at the controls, and would remain so for the next couple of hours. Eldar had been sitting in the captains seat for three minutes before he became emboldened enough to ask, presumably gesturing at the control column, Can I turn this? But if Piskaryov wanted to push the controls forward to level off, he might have been unable to do so the diminutive copilot topped out at just 160cm (53), and his seat was pushed all the way back to the stop. Incredibly, amid the banter in the cockpit, no one noticed that something was wrong. 45 as a result of which it also caught fire. Once the pilots regained control, they attempted to pull out of the dive. anonymously (anonymous users cannot post links). In a Russian-designed plane, the alerts are audible, yet the one they were flying gave silent notification. Furiously working the controls, Kudrinsky managed to stabilize their roll angle at 20 degrees left, and together the pilots started to pull the plane out of the dive, from 90 degrees nose down to just 20. It is said that most of the passengers onboard were businessmen from Hong Kong and Taiwan who were traveling for business opportunities in Russia. Although he tried to obey his fathers order, he was physically unable to move. - Listen to Aeroflot Flight 593 by Plane Crash Podcast instantly on your tablet, phone or browser - no downloads needed. See less. The Airbus A310 operating the flight had earlier arrived from London with several connecting passengers, but the second leg of the journey was lightly booked, with just 63 passengers on board, including numerous businessmen and several off-duty Aeroflot employees. In response, Eldar held his control column in the neutral position, while Piskaryov attempted to bank back to the left. This triggered a series of events that led to the plane crashing, killing 63 passengers and 12 crew members. EN RU CN DE ES. SpiceJet announces six flights to Bangkok from March 10. Although such warnings are ubiquitous today, in 1994 most planes did not have bank angle warnings. Over the next few minutes, however, Kudrinsky steadily upped the ante, drifting from questionable judgment into blatant unprofessionalism. The aircraft, registration ZK-NEY, a de Havilland Canada DHC-8 Dash 8, was manufactured in Canada in 1986. Aeroflot Flight 593 was a passenger flight from Sheremetyevo International Airport, Moscow, Russia, to Kai Tak Airport in Hong Kong. First, his daughter Yana took the pilot's left front seat. Weve reached an area, a holding area, Piskaryov agreed. Having been alerted to the issue, however, the pilots failed to follow the principle of aviate, navigate, communicate they tried to figure out why the plane was turning before attempting to stop it. Shit, not again2388 '''Kudrinsky:''' Don't turn it right! After this, the aircraft began to stall and automatically entered a dive to recover. It existed only so that a pilot could react immediately in the event of a sudden departure from controlled flight while the plane was on autopilot. topic's main category. | Today is Saturday, March 23, the 82nd day of 2019. ''Piskaryov pulls out of the dive, but over-corrects. The plane ascending in this position somehow? All 63 passengers and 12 crew members perished in the accident. The pilots tried to balance it again, but the altitude it had gained was out of recovery and thereby it crashed into the Kuznetsk Alatau mountain range. Statements. The A310 cannot turn this steeply while maintaining altitude, and the plane started to descend quickly. Okay, watch the ground, where youre going to turn. Kudrinsky instructed. Pilot's CHILDREN in Control! Yes, Kudrinsky said without hesitation. On 23 March 1994, theaircraftwas en route fromSheremetyevo International AirporttoKai Tak AirportinHong Kongwith 75 occupants aboard, of whom 63 were passengers. Despite being Aeroflots best of the best, neither pilot had undergone this training, and neither had ever attempted to recover from a high bank angle upset before. Simultaneously, the airplane stalled, suffering a catastrophic loss of lift, triggering a stall warning for four seconds before the autopilot alarm overrode it. Tragically, investigators noted that after the first spin, when Kudrinsky had wrangled the plane into a 20-degree nose down position with 20 degrees of left bank, recovery would have been assured if he had simply let go of the controls. SpiceJet announces six flights to Bangkok from March 10, Know What Congress Leader Rahul Gandhi Says in Cambridge University in China, Jammu and Kashmir : Rahul Gandhi's statement on Pulwama attack. As political chaos, runaway inflation, and shortages of basic goods spread throughout Russia, no industry escaped upheaval, including the airlines. In total, Aeroflots A310 division was composed of five aircraft on lease from a holding company and registered in France. The speed! Piskaryov exclaimed. Its automation was considered sophisticated when it first entered service in 1983, but by 1992 it no longer stood out from the crowd. In their report, the MAK wrote that Kudrinskys decision to let Eldar move the control column showed an utterly careless and irresponsible disregard for flight safety, the result of poor discipline and a blatant ignorance of the rules contained in [the civil aviation regulations.]. ''Altitude warnings, autopilot disengagement warnings, and stall warnings sound in quick succession. Full power! Forced to redefine itself in a radically different economy, Aeroflot sought to shed its reputation for uncomfortable airplanes and poor service by transforming itself into a modern airline which would not only improve Russias international reputation, but normalize flying on Aeroflot as a viable means of travel for businesspeople and tourists from around the world, regardless of whether Russia was their final destination. Mauganj As 53rd District Is BJP's Next Poll Bet With Eye On Vindhya Region, Calcutta High Court Clears Way For ED To Take Anubrata Mondal To Delhi, Excise Policy Case: CBI Confronts Sisodia With Ex-Bureaucrats During Grilling, GG-W: 64-9 (15.1) | MI-W vs GG-W, WPL 2023 Cricket Live Score & Updates, NCP Keeps Cards Close To Its Chest In Meghalaya Ahead Of Govt Formation, Need For 'New Engine' As Corruption Doubles In 'Double-Engine' Govt: Kejriwal, Disha Patani Grabs Eyeballs In Vintage Cat Woman Look: PICS, 'Islamabad Has Unique Distinction For Hosting': India Slams Pak At UNHRC, Jacqueline Fernandez STUNS In Glam Avatar, Looks Breathtaking Beautiful In New Song 'Deewaane', Happy Birthday Natasa Stankovic: 5 Times Hardik Pandya's Lovely Wife Bowled Over Fans With Hotness - In Pics. They were still falling rapidly, but the rate of descent was starting to decrease as they pulled out of the dive. The children's actions and distraction in the cockpit contributed to the crash. Two altitude alert warnings sounded as the plane left its programmed altitude, followed by a loud autopilot disconnect alarm as Piskaryovs inputs finally exceeded the disconnect threshold of the vertical channel. >Those who survived the initial crash had to listen to everyone else around them screaming in pain and burning to death or dying from exposure all night. A New Hampshire man who crashed his Cessna 310 on New Year's Day in 2011, killing his daughter, . While it incorporated some relatively advanced autoflight systems, it was not a fly-by-wire aircraft it still had direct connections between the cockpit and the flight controls. Throughout the flight, the plane had been flying on autopilot, with its vertical channel in altitude hold mode to keep the plane at 10,100 meters, while the lateral channel navigated the plane along a pre-programmed string of waypoints stretching all the way from Moscow to Hong Kong. Okay [sobbing] Full power!
2365 '''Piskaryov:''' Speed is very high2367 '''Kudrinsky:''' High, is it?2368 '''Piskaryov:''' Yes, isn't it?2369 '''Kudrinsky:''' I switched it off2371 '''Piskaryov:''' We're coming out, coming out!2377 '''Kudrinsky:''' Done2382 '''Piskaryov:''' Gently! During the flight, children of the relief pilot visited the cockpit where Yana took the pilot's left front seat. The New York Timesalso stated that an analysis by an aviation expert published inRossiiskiye Vestisupported that analysis. The disengaged autopilot caused the aircraft to lose control. Hold it, hold the column, hold it! Kudrinsky shouted at both Piskaryov and Eldar. Instead, they seem to have concluded that the autopilot had inadvertently placed them into a holding pattern above a navigational waypoint an annoying issue which was not unheard of in the complex airspace over the former Soviet Union. | Aeroflot Flight 593 Mentour Pilot 1.4M subscribers Subscribe 1.6M views 10 months ago Go to https://blinkist.com/mentourpilot for a 7 DAY FREE TRIAL + 25% OFF. This would have caused a change in the feedback forces on the control columns as the resistance put up by the autopilot abruptly vanished, but Eldar could not have been expected to notice, and Piskaryov probably thought the change in feedback was because of an input by Eldar. This was probably because they believed the autopilot was engaged, and did not think the autopilot could do anything dangerous to the flight path, reducing their sense of urgency. Full power! crashed airliner. Meanwhile, Kudrinsky continued to shout at his son. The aircraft was subjected to an astonishing 4.7 Gs, far exceeding the design limit load. The CVR recording left little doubt that the pilots had lost control while relief Captain Kudrinsky was demonstrating the planes capabilities to his children, and that at various points the children were actually sitting in the captains seat and manipulating the controls. The aircraft suffered an electrical failure and returned to Sheremetyevo for an emergency landing. Because he was fighting Eldar, and because the disrupted airflow over the wings was reducing the effectiveness of the ailerons, his inputs were ineffective, and the plane continued rolling to the right. Relief pilot Kudrinsky was taking his two children on their first international flight, and they were brought to thecockpitwhile he was on duty. He might therefore have been unaware that it was the autopilot which was trying to turn back to the left, and not Eldar. Nobody was monitoring the instruments, except apparently Eldar, who was the first to observe that the plane was banking excessively. But why is it doing that? said Kudrinsky. Set the horizon to normal for him, Makarov interjected. The plane, however, was stalling and entered into the corkscrew dive. $158. Aeroflot flight 593 was a flight from Moscow to Hong Kong. Contribute to chinapedia/wikipedia.en development by creating an account on GitHub. The crash of Aeroflot Flight 593 happened when the pilot's 16-year-old son disengaged the autopilot when he was in the cockpit with his father and sister. Seconds later, however, Kudrinsky switched the autopilot to HDG/SEL mode and used the heading knob to enter a leftward heading, causing the autopilot to turn the plane to the left in line with Eldars inputs. As for Aeroflots special A310 division, the final report proved to be its death knell, and Russian Airlines was unceremoniously absorbed back into the parent company in 1995. Here, the MAK turned its criticism on Airbus, calling into question the compliance of the design with Russian regulations, which required the engagement, disengagement, or change of mode of any autoflight system to be accompanied by a corresponding indication; and the International Civil Aviation Organizations guidelines, which stated that there should be an appropriate indication for any inadvertent change or disengagement of a mode. In the event, however, this partial disconnection was not accompanied by any sort of warning or indication, and in fact the autopilot mode display would have continued to suggest that NAV mode was active, even though it was not. ago On the 21st episode of PCPC, Michael and Tess focus on Aeroflot Flight 593, a scheduled flight from Sheremetyevo International Airport in Moscow to Kai Tak Airport in Hong Kong, on the night of March 23rd 1994. Maksim Moiseev tried to . For a few minutes, Kudrinsky explained various aspects of the plane and what made it special, but he had bigger ideas, too. Aeroflot Flight 1492 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight operated by Aeroflot from Moscow-Sheremetyevo to Murmansk, Russia. 593 593 1994 323 A310-304 [1] 593 [ ] [2] A310-304 F-OGQS 1739 75 We empathize with the terror he must have felt in the flights final minutes, knowing that he was fighting to save not only his own life and his passengers lives, but the lives of his beloved son and daughter as well. When Aeroflot was a pan-USSR airline and the biggest carrier in the world, the workhorse was the Tupolev 154. Comments. ), Visit r/admiralcloudberg to read and discuss over 230 similar articles. If they had, then the outcome might have been very different. According to Russian aviation regulations, bringing guests into the cockpit of a passenger flight while en route was not, still is not, and never has been permitted. Shortly thereafter, Kudrinsky's son Eldar occupied the pilot's seat. Then, it seems, he got another dubious idea: Hey Yana, are you going to fly it? he said. Since the turn was continuous, the resulting predicted flight path drawn on screen was a 180-degree turn. Full power Piskaryov bellowed, and Kudrinsky jammed the throttles forward. In fact, the level of aviation safety in Russia fell dramatically from late Soviet levels beginning in 1991, and did not begin to recover until approximately 2010. Nashville Fire Department Union Contract, Dobre Brothers Fan Mail Address, Articles A